Sorry about removing the name of the company. I hope you understand -- we get a lot of people coming through here who try to "sneak in" a bit of promotion for themselves or their clients. I'm not saying that was the case in this situation, but to avoid the appearance
of promoting any one company over others that might provide the same sort of service, I thought it was better to keep the discussion more generic.
That said, given the facts as you laid them out here, what is the dilemma? Assuming you've done your due diligence, followed up with references and feel the second company is reputable, it sounds like a good deal. What specific concerns do you have that are causing you to hesitate?